How to Visit Catalina Island on a Tight Budget: Local Tips from Bre
Hi, I’m Bre — a Catalina Island local for 9 years, raising my family here and running Avalon History Tours. I know firsthand that Catalina’s beauty can sometimes feel out of reach if you’re watching your budget, but I’m here to tell you it’s totally doable to enjoy this island paradise without spending a fortune.
If you’re dreaming of that iconic Catalina blue water, stunning harbor views, and unique island vibes, but need to keep costs down, here’s my personal guide to exploring Catalina Island on a budget.
1. Take the Catalina Flyer with Groupon Deals
Getting here is your first big expense, but there are ways to save:
Catalina Flyer offers daily round-trip service from Newport Beach to Avalon, taking about 75 minutes each way.
Look for Groupon deals — they often offer up to 30% off on round-trip tickets.
Parking: If you're driving, parking near the Balboa Pier is limited and can be expensive. Arrive early to find a spot or consider using Uber or rideshare options to save on parking fees.
2. Stay Smart: Affordable Lodging Options in Avalon
Glenmore Plaza Hotel
As Catalina Island’s oldest hotel, the Glenmore Plaza Hotel offers a unique blend of Victorian charm and modern amenities. Built in 1891 by the same crew that constructed the Hotel Del Coronado, this historic hotel has hosted luminaries like Theodore Roosevelt, Charlie Chaplin, and Clark Gable.
Despite its rich history, the Glenmore Plaza Hotel provides modern comforts, including air-conditioned rooms, flat-screen TVs, and complimentary continental breakfast. Many rooms have been recently renovated to include marble bathrooms and private balconies with partial ocean or mountain views.
Located just steps from the beach and the heart of Avalon, the Glenmore Plaza Hotel offers a convenient and affordable base for exploring the island.
www.glenmoreplaza.com
Hermosa Hotel
The Hermosa Hotel is another budget-friendly option in Avalon, offering a range of accommodations from standard rooms to cottages. It first opened in 1896 and is known for having some of the best prices in Avalon. While some guests have noted that the hotel could benefit from updates, it remains a popular choice for travelers seeking an affordable stay in a central location.
The Hermosa Hotel is situated within walking distance of the beach, shops, and restaurants, making it a convenient choice for those looking to explore Avalon on foot.
https://hotels.cloudbeds.com/
3. Eat Like a Local Without Overspending
If dining out feels pricey, just hit up Vons grocery store for deli sandwiches, pre-made salads, or snacks to save some cash. Catalina’s got food options for all budgets.
🍕 Antonio’s Pizzeria & Deli – A Slice of Avalon History
Established in 1977, Original Antonio’s Pizzeria & Deli is a cherished local institution located at 114 Sumner Avenue. Known for its retro 1950s ambiance, this cozy spot serves up hearty pizzas, pastas, and sandwiches. Signature dishes include the sourdough pepperoni pizza, garlic cheese bread, and a local favorite “cheese crisp”. The eatery also offers beer and wine, making it a perfect place to relax after a day of exploring. Whether you choose to dine in or grab a slice to go, Antonio’s provides an affordable and satisfying meal for all ages.
🌮 The Sand Trap – Casual Eats with a Local Vibe
Located near the Catalina Island Golf Course, The Sand Trap is a laid-back spot favored by locals and golfers alike. They serve a variety of breakfast and lunch options, including omelets, huevos rancheros, tacos, burgers, and sandwiches. The restaurant features a full bar and offers outdoor seating, making it a great place to enjoy a meal in the fresh air. Happy hour is available daily from 2 p.m. to 7 p.m., featuring $2 tacos, $3 draft beers, and $6 margaritas, & $22 margarita pitchers. You really can’t beat the price.
🌶️ The Buffalo Nickel – A Local Favorite with a Free Shuttle
One of my personal favorite spots on the island—and a beloved local hangout—is The Buffalo Nickel. Nestled on Pebbly Beach Road near the helicopter pad, it's a bit off the beaten path, but that's part of its charm. The restaurant offers a cozy atmosphere, generous portions, and a menu that blends Mexican and American flavors.
One of their standout offerings is the Buffalo Milk cocktail—a creamy, indulgent drink that's become a must-try for visitors. In fact, the drink is worthy of its very own blog. Pair it with their ceviche, fish tacos, or the popular baby back ribs for a satisfying meal.
Getting there is easy, thanks to their free shuttle service. Simply call ahead, and they'll pick you up from the Carbillo Mole (the Catalina Express dock area). This makes it convenient for those without a golf cart or who prefer not to walk the approximately 1.5-mile stretch to the restaurant. The shuttle service ensures you can enjoy your meal without worrying about transportation back to town. Whether you're a local or a visitor, The Buffalo Nickel offers a warm, welcoming environment and delicious food that keeps people coming back.
🌊 4. Free and Low-Cost Fun on Catalina
There’s plenty to do on Catalina that costs little to nothing:
Spend a day relaxing at Descanso Beach — you can bring your own towels and chairs and enjoy the water and sun without paying for the cabanas.
Walk the Avalon waterfront and harbor promenade for beautiful views, people-watching, and soaking up the island vibe.
Take a hike on the Hermit Gulch Trail — a short, easy path with great views and native plants.
Visit the Catalina Island Museum on their community discount days or explore public art around town. Nestled a short stroll up Metropole Avenue, the Catalina Island Museum for Art & History is a must-visit spot that brings Avalon’s story—both ancient and modern—to life with style.
🛺 5. Budget-Friendly Touring: Meet Gary the Garibaldi
If you want to experience Catalina’s stories and sights but don’t want to spend a lot, I highly recommend Gary the Garibaldi’s City Tour. It’s a fun, affordable ride around Avalon with local history, fun facts, and plenty of photo ops.
It’s perfect for families, cruise visitors, or anyone who wants to see the island’s highlights without too much walking or expense.
🛶 6. Paddle, Snorkel & Explore with Wet Spot Rentals
If you want to get out on the water without spending a fortune, Wet Spot Rentals is the place to go. Located right at Float 5 (near the Catalina Express), they offer affordable, easy-to-rent gear for your ocean adventure.
Kayaks start at just $20/hour, perfect for paddling around Avalon Bay or heading toward the kelp forests near Lovers Cove.
Snorkel gear (mask, fins, snorkel) is only $15 for two hours, and they often throw in an extra hour—great value for a close-up look at Catalina’s famous Garibaldi fish.
Stand-up paddleboards are also available for $25 per hour, and the friendly staff is happy to give quick tips if you’re new to the water.
This is a favorite among locals and a great option if you’re traveling with kids, friends, or just want to spend a peaceful afternoon on the water without a tour guide or time pressure.
wetspotrentals.com
🪂 7. Soar Over Avalon with California Parasail
For a truly unforgettable experience (that still won’t wreck your budget), check out California Parasail located on Pebbly Beach Road (105 Pebbly Beach Rd)
Choose from 600 ft ($69) or 800 ft ($79) flights.
Take advantage of early bird discounts before 11 AM—you can fly for only $50 per person!
Want to watch but not fly? They offer a $25 ride-along option so you can enjoy the boat and snap some great photos.
This is one of the most exciting ways to see Catalina, and it’s surprisingly easy to fit into a budget trip. Just bring your sense of adventure—and maybe a camera!
https://californiaparasail.com/catalina-island/
🧳 8. Plan Ahead and Pack Smart
Bring your own refillable water bottle—there are free water stations located near the Knabe Pirate Park and Avalon Kids Park!
Pack sunscreen and snacks so you’re not paying island prices for basics.
Book your ferry and tours online early to lock in the best rates.
Bring comfortable shoes if you plan to explore on foot or hike.
🌟 Final Thoughts from a Local
Catalina Island is a magical place that doesn’t have to cost a fortune to enjoy. With a little planning, you can soak up the island’s unique charm, natural beauty, and rich history — all while keeping your budget intact.
If you want a local guide to help you get the most out of your visit without the extra expense, I’d love to show you around. From Gary the Garibaldi’s City Tour to my in-depth Avalon History Walking Tour, there’s something for every budget and interest.
Looking forward to welcoming you to Catalina soon!
🌺 Bre
Avalon History Tours
